Cassie's Picks · Practical puppy shopping
Puppy Teething Toys: Two Small KONG Options Compared
Start with one appropriately sized toy and learn how your puppy uses it. A large multipack is less useful if most of its pieces are the wrong size or do not hold up to your puppy's chewing.
By the Sage Puppies editorial team · Researched October 10, 2026
We may earn a commission when you buy through product links in this article. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
These are researched options based on manufacturer specifications and current product listings. We have not verified hands-on testing by Cassie. Prices, availability and variants can change.
The quick decision
Choose the classic hollow KONG Puppy if you want a toy with a cavity for appropriate food filling. Choose the Puppy Goodie Bone if you prefer a bone shape with treat openings at the ends. Both are puppy rubber toys for supervised play; neither is indestructible.
Puppy playtime from the Sage Puppies photo library. The toys pictured are not evidence of testing the products below.
Two researched toys, two different shapes
KONG Puppy, Small Blue
The linked option is the Small Blue KONG Puppy, one toy. Its hollow center gives you a food-filling option as well as a rubber toy to investigate and chew.
When it fits: Consider it for a young puppy whose mouth size and chewing style suit this size. Start simply, with an appropriate portion of food your puppy already tolerates, rather than making the filling difficult to reach.
What to check or skip: Small is not automatically correct for every small-breed puppy. Follow KONG's sizing guidance and move to a larger or different toy when needed. KONG does not recommend Puppy rubber for dogs over nine months.
KONG Puppy Goodie Bone, Small Blue
The linked option is the Small Blue Puppy Goodie Bone without rope. Treat openings at the ends offer a different filling format from the classic KONG's central cavity.
When it fits: Consider it when you want a simple bone shape for supervised play and your puppy can handle the size appropriately. Compare the openings and shape with what your puppy enjoys using.
What to check or skip: It duplicates some of the classic toy's role, so you do not need both on day one. This is the puppy version, not the adult Goodie Bone or the extra-small rope version. Follow the same age, size and damage checks.
What makes a toy worth buying?
Look for a clearly identified model, size and material, plus useful manufacturer instructions. A familiar brand and favorable buyer reviews help narrow the shortlist, but they cannot prove a toy will suit your individual puppy.
Avoid choosing by color, a giant piece count or an “indestructible” claim. Consider whether you can clean the toy easily and inspect its surface and openings. If you cannot tell which variant you are ordering, pause and check the listing.
A simple first-week toy rotation
Introduce one toy while you are with your puppy. Observe whether the puppy chews it, carries it or loses interest. Put it away afterward, inspect it, and rotate it back into play another time.
You can add a different kind of toy for a different activity: an appropriately sized plush toy for supervised carrying, or a toy for gentle interactive play. Choose those after observing your puppy, instead of treating a big starter bundle as a requirement.
Supervision and replacement matter
KONG advises supervising play and removing damaged toys. Check before and after use, and retire a toy if pieces are coming loose or your puppy is trying to swallow it. Follow the manufacturer's instructions rather than leaving a new toy with a puppy unattended.
Use food fillings within your puppy's normal feeding plan. Ask your veterinarian about suitable ingredients when your puppy has dietary restrictions. A toy is enrichment, not treatment for dental pain; contact your veterinarian about painful chewing, damaged teeth or other concerns.
Questions before you add to cart
Which one should I buy first? The classic hollow toy is the more direct choice for a central food cavity; the bone offers a different shape and end openings. There is no need to buy both before you know your puppy's preferences.
Is a small toy suitable for my Cavapoo or Havapoo? The breed label is only a starting point. Check the puppy's mouth size, chewing behavior and the manufacturer's guidance.
Where do toys fit in the starter budget? After food, bowls, a resting space and practical care supplies. Use our supply checklist to separate essentials from extras.
More help for your puppy shopping
Christmas gifts for small puppies
A first-week setup with less clutter
Browse Cassie's Picks for more researched product guides.
Planning for a Sage puppy?
Sage Puppies is a Utah-based Havanese, Havapoo and Cavapoo program. When you are ready to explore the puppies and our process, start with our current availability.
